The Research and Editorial Office of
Professor Barry H.V. Topping

Electronic Review Form for
The International Journal of Computers and Structures
The International Journal of Advances in Engineering Software
and their Special Issues

This page is the electronic gateway to send reviews to Professor Barry H.V. Topping for papers submitted to Computers and Structures, Advances in Engineering Software or their Special Issues.

Now please complete all the details required on the form below.

Review reference number:
///R/
Paper title:

Authors (without affiliations):

Reviewer's recommendation:
AcceptNo amendment required.
Reviewer suggests amendment but this is not mandatory.
Paper accepted on condition that Reviewer's requests are complied with.
RejectAuthor should consider the suggestions of Reviewer and re-submit paper.
Paper is unacceptable. Reasons for objections are below.

If this is a Special Issue review, which journal should this paper be published in?
Computers & Structures
Advances in Engineering Software

Reviewer's overall rating of the paper:
of major significance
important technical information
average
poor

For the paper:
Is the title adequate?
Are the summary and conclusions adequate?
Is the arrangement of material suitable?
Is adequate reference made to other works in the field?
Are any portions of the paper, or any illustrations unnecessary?
Can any material be deleted without detriment?
Is there any defamatory material in the paper?
Did the author publish a similar paper before?

General comments for the author. (Note: Referee's names are held in strictest confidence. Please make sure you do not mention anything that may identify you.)
Please type your name to sign this review.

Please press the following button to continue

If your comments can not be submitted as plain text in the box above or if you wish to send your comments as a separate file, please email them as an attachment to cas, aes or sis AT bhvt.org.uk. Please make sure that you include in your email the review reference number.

Thank you for using the electronic review submission gateway.

return to the main page